even searle himself should be too smart to fall for his chinese room argument and that's part of what pisses me off. plus when people point out giant flaws he just smugface.jpg and calls them idiots.

· tootstream · 0 · 1 · 2

@enkiv2 yeah, when i was studying it, i thought that the premise of the thought experiment was incredulous

I would half-like to run into him sometime just to mention that, as a materialist, he must be claiming that chinese people also don't speak chinese!

(Since having a 'semantics' that cannot be represented in the configuration of material as a prerequisite for 'knowing' only makes sense if that 'semantics' is isolated to a non-physical plane like that of platonic forms.)

@enkiv2 You're right on point, and this might be gossip, but didn't he backpedal from his theory in years since, too?

He still maintained it in a 2010 lecture at Google. If he backpedaled since, I haven't heard.

@enkiv2 Very good, that's why I wasn't sure, it sounds like something I might have misheard.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Welcome to your niu world ! We are a cute and loving international community O(≧▽≦)O !
We are a moderated instance, that aren't supporting harassment nor hateful speech, so what sets us apart? Well, unlike many instances like us, we won't prevent you to interact with instances that aren't respecting our rules.
The main language used here is English, but for most of us this isn't our main language, so it's a great place to learn!

Topics you might find here

Here, we are open to any subjects, but the main ones are:
Fictions / Animes / Mangas / Comics
Gaming / e-Sport / Retro / Speedrun
Programming / Security / IT stuffs
Sometime politics / World events
Pictures and story from around the world <3