One software freedom that Stallman does not mention is the freedom *not* to use the program because you dislike or don't want it for some reason

Free software tends to be flexible, have clear boundaries, split responsibilities, and replaceable components, thanks in part to openly defined protocols and formats

Proprietary software tends to want to lock you in into their freaking ecosystem, and even if they adopt an open standard, it's a part of an E-E-E strategy

@Wolf480pl I'm a fan of systemd actually :) it is free software and it is quite modular, contrary to some beliefs. Different distros ship with different sets of systemd components. Wouldn't hurt for it to be even more modular, such as supporting elogind (being able to use logins without systemd the PID 1) upstream.

Last time I checked, systemd had no open standards (maybe except unit file format). libsystemd's API is the only thing you're supposed to depend on, and the communication methods used for socket activation, startup notification, communication between udev and systemd, communication between systemd and logind, etc. are declared as implementation details and subject to change without notice.

Also, things like systemd-networkd, systemd-resolved, systemd-timesyncd, etc. look to me like a blend of EEE and scope creep.

@Wolf480pl what? systemd (the PID 1) spawns your process using Unix's standard fork() + exec(), and passes you journal fd as standard IO, and socket fds using the standard Unix fd passing. Most public APIs of systemd components are even exported as clearly documented D-Bus interfaces. Honestly some projects could learn from systemd :)


>Most public APIs of systemd components are even exported as clearly documented D-Bus interfaces

Ok, could you please point me to something docunenting how udev interacts with systemd? I've always wondered how this works and how hard it'd be to reimplement the whole multiseat thing without systemd.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Welcome to your niu world ! We are a cute and loving international community O(≧▽≦)O !